Has the Next Credit Collapse Already Begun?

Submitted by William Bonner, Chairman – Bonner & Partners

The Climate Fix Is In

PARIS – The big news over the weekend was that the Paris meeting of climate foxes produced an agreement. They will spend $16.5 trillion of other people’s money to raise more chickens.

“Forget ‘Big Oil,’” proclaimed a Bloomberg headline, “Get Ready for ‘Big Solar.’”


solar_np1Solar panels covered in snow. Obviously, we need more “global warming” to get them to work, so it is a bit unfortunate that there hasn’t been any warming in nearly 20 years. Hell, we can’t even get any bad weather anymore! It should be a tough time for the alarmist crowd, but there is a lot of money at stake – global warming hysteria is easily one of the greatest rackets and gravy trains in all of history – arguably only exceeded by the war racket. Yes, someone is always making off with the loot in these “green energy” boondoggles. It ain’t you or me, dear reader. We have been chosen to play the part of involuntary providers of the loot. As Bill Bonner notes below: the fix is in.

Photo credit: National Post


We don’t have any knowledge or prejudice on the subject. But it sounds like the fix is in.

Like the War on Drugs, the War on Poverty, and the War on Terror, we predict that the War on Carbon Emissions will prove successful – but only for the warriors.


Near Certain

But how do we know? How do we know anything? The future, as we remind ourselves almost daily, is a movie that hasn’t been released yet. A reader wonders:


“I am a new subscriber and just getting a feel for the tone and quality of information presented in your Diary and your newsletter. A contradiction emerges: How do you reconcile your near certainty of a deflation induced collapse of the credit system with your view that one can never know the future?”


Glad you asked. Most people strongly believe – they are “near certain” – that the sky will light up tomorrow morning just like it does every day. No one knows for sure. But it is probably a mistake to bet against it.

Likewise, if you are working in one of Baltimore’s poor neighborhoods, and you leave your tools in an open van, don’t expect them to be there when you come back. Just sayin’…

Markets follow patterns. They go up. They go down. Economies, too, have their good hair days and their bad hair days.


Credit cyclesThe credit cycle illustrated. If one erroneously believes that the central planners at the Fed can somehow “help” the economy or that they have any appreciable degree of control over what is going to happen, one only needs to look at this chart to realize that this cannot possibly be true. The next step then is to ask: Why is it not true? And why do they persist in doing what they are doing when it should be blindingly obvious to even a five year old child that they cannot possibly succeed in their official task? Asking these questions and looking for the answers to them will disabuse one of a great many illusions – click to enlarge.


There are cycles in all aspects of human life. We are born. But we die, too. Our cities, countries, and empires flourish… and then stagnate and decay. We breathe in… and out. We are happy… then we get the blues.

Long observed and carefully described are the cycles in the credit market. Interest rates – which track the ups and downs – do not go only in one direction. Sometimes, they back up. They change their minds and turn around.


planningIf only they had carried the “1”, everything would be copacetic!


One Direction

You can see why this has to be so. Imagine if interest rates only went in one direction. Investors would know the future. They would anticipate the direction of the market (correctly) and buy investments to take advantage of it.

But how? Who would sell? Who would want to be on the other side of the trade? If rates only went up, who would bet on lower ones?

No… If people knew the future, there would be no need for markets (the purpose of which is to “discover” prices). And the present would become a monotonous blur of sameness.


T bond yieldAnother chart illustrating the great success of “scientific monetary policy” and the stability it has produced. It is also a reminder of the fact that whatever people happen to most strongly believe near market extremes will eventually turn out to be completely wrong – click to enlarge.


But markets cannot be obliterated. When they are outlawed… they go underground. When they are delayed… they build up energy. When they are denied… they reassert themselves, with a vengeance.

Credit expansions are enabled by low real (inflation-adjusted) interest rates. Credit contractions occur when real rates go up. That can happen because investors are afraid they won’t get paid back, or because they fear the money they get back will have less buying power than the money they lent.

Either way, real rates go up… and credit contracts.

After 66 years of credit expansion, and 33 years of a falling trend in interest rates, we expect a reversal. As Deutsche Bank dryly puts it, “U.S. looks late in the cycle on a macro and micro basis…

A “near certainty”? Probably not. A good bet? Probably.

And poor Janet Yellen – sheltered in the academic and regulatory world all her adult life – is about to see for herself.


How rate hike decisions are really made.


The fix has been in for the past seven years. Investors knew – with “near certainty” – that the Fed wouldn’t allow long-term rates to rise. This week, she is supposed to begin “normalizing” the situation by raising short-term interest rates.

But markets don’t reward the wishful thinking of regulators or the claptrap theories of professors. They have minds of their own. Stay tuned…